Season 2
01 Gotham, The Good Place, The Black Cauldron
30mKirk Damato, Marisha Ray, and Brennan Lee Mulligan write Avatar fan fiction and stan Entwives.
2019-07-20
02 A Very Special TV-Themed Episode
30mRekha Shankar, Joan Ford, and Janie Stolar liken Mr. Big to Trump in an obsessive homage to classic TV.
2019-07-27
03 Homestar Runner, Hearthstone, Demolition Man
27mAlly Beardsley, Ify Nwadiwe, and Ryanni name gnomes and match prosthetics to their fictional owners.
2019-08-03
04 The Dresden Files, Settlers of Catan, Fallout 4
29mErika Ishii, Eme Ikwuakor, and Becca Scott hoard video game items and dream of Beholders.
2019-08-10
05 Predator, Mistborn, The Expanse
28mShane Crown, Luke Field, and Danielle Radford spot the fake wrestler and feel sorry for dragons.
2019-08-17
06 Scott Pilgrim, Highlander, Dr. Doom
27mSam Bashor, Ryan Martin, and Tao Yang apply to superhero college and arrange robots by size.
2019-08-24
07 The Musical Theater Episode
29mRachel Bloom, Grant O'Brien, and Siobhan Thompson test their playbill memories in a musical-themed ep.
2019-08-31
08 Stephen King, Warhammer 40,000, Dragon Age
28mJordan Doll, Nick Marini, and Liam Senior mistrust Lakitu's impartiality and debate if Donatello's cool.
2019-09-07
09 Sailor Moon, Pacific Rim, Fate/Stay Night
34mKen Napzok, Emma Fyffe, and Michelle Nguyen Bradley size up spaceships and say no to butt brains.
2019-09-14
10 Ghostbusters, Gateway, Gravity Falls
32mZac Oyama, Caldwell Tanner, and Frank Garcia-Hejl pinpoint pirates and find the fake Simpsons character.
2019-09-21
11 Um, Actually LIVE! @ New York Comic Con
53mMike Drucker, Alex Song, and Carolyn Page compete with fan Jamel Wood in a LIVE episode from NYCC 2019.
2019-10-12
12 Star Trek, Godzilla Island, Babylon 5
33mAlex Schmidt, Zac Oyama, and Haley Mancini beat up vampires and find the darker side of Roger Rabbit.
2019-10-19
13 Um, Aaah!ctually: Halloween Edition
35mBetsy Sodaro, Jessica Ross, and Oscar Montoya test their horror knowledge in a special spooky episode.
2019-10-26
14 E.T., Green Lantern, Robin Hobb
35mKirk Damato, Liam Senior, and Noah Diamond-Stolzman boycott the Triwizard Cup and play "Name That Elf."
2019-11-02
15 Venture Brothers, Full Metal Alchemist, Conan the Barbarian
31mTao Yang, David Gallegos, and Dani Fernandez cozy up to H.P. Lovecraft and test their acronym knowledge.
2019-11-09
16 Buffy the Vampire Slayer, M. Night Shyamalan, Final Fantasy X
33mLuke Field, Eli Yudin, and Joan Ford feed the fictional and get sloppy with their Death Notes.
2019-11-16
17 Borderlands, Ticket to Ride, Into the Spider-Verse
32mJenny Lorenzo, Nick Marini, and Erika Ishii muse over mythical maps and count Aristocats' lives.
2019-11-23
18 Rick & Morty, The Muppets, Superman
32mMaggie Mae Fish, Jessica Ross, and Jon Gutierrez chug Felix Felicis and dish about Kermit's old flame.
2019-11-30
19 Ho Ho Ho, Actually: The Holiday Special
30mShane Crown, Jon Gutierrez, and Amy Vorpahl celebrate fictional holidays & play "name that Santa."
2019-12-08
20 Ender’s Game, Good Omens, Secret Wars
32mLily Du, Amy Dallen, and Emma Fyffe read tabloids for wizards and match origin stories to superheroes.
2019-12-14
21 Pokémon, South Park, Discworld
27mShay Parsons, T.J. Gonzalez, and Jessica Clemons join Squirtle's squad and identify cartoon pet sounds.
2019-12-21
Who is in it
Ify NwadiweSelf - Host
Brian David GilbertSelf - Fact Checker